Foods to Avoid While Breastfeeding: Separating Fact from Fiction

Introduction

You’ve probably heard conflicting advice about what you can and can’t eat while breastfeeding. Your mother-in-law says to avoid spicy foods, your friend swears dairy causes gas, and that article you read claims you need to eliminate a dozen different foods from your diet. So what’s the truth?

The good news is that most breastfeeding mothers can eat a normal, varied diet without worrying about restricting foods. However, there are a few items worth being cautious about, and some babies do react to certain foods in mom’s diet. Let’s separate the myths from the facts and help you make informed choices about your diet while nursing.

The General Rule: Eat Normally

Here’s the most important thing to understand: most breastfeeding mothers can eat whatever they want. Your body is remarkably efficient at producing nutritious milk regardless of your diet. Unless you notice a specific reaction in your baby, there’s no need to restrict your eating.

In fact, exposing your baby to various flavors through breast milk may actually help them become less picky eaters later. Breast milk flavor changes based on your diet, giving baby a “taste” of your family’s cuisine.

That said, there are some foods worth being mindful of and a few that should be limited or avoided. Let’s break them down.

Foods That May Affect Your Baby

1. Caffeine

Why it matters: Caffeine passes into breast milk and can accumulate in your baby’s system since babies metabolize it much more slowly than adults.

What’s safe:

• Up to 300mg of caffeine per day is generally considered safe (about 2-3 cups of coffee)
• Peak caffeine levels in breast milk occur 1-2 hours after consumption
• If your baby seems fussy, has trouble sleeping, or is more alert than usual, try reducing caffeine

Sources to watch:

• Coffee (95mg per 8oz cup)
• Tea (47mg per 8oz cup)
• Energy drinks (80-300mg per can)
• Soda (34-45mg per 12oz)
• Chocolate (12-25mg per ounce of dark chocolate)
• Some medications (check labels)

Tips:

• If you’re a coffee lover, have your cup right after nursing to maximize time before the next feed
• Watch for cumulative effects from multiple caffeine sources
• Remember that newborns are more sensitive than older babies

2. Alcohol

Why it matters: Alcohol passes into breast milk at the same concentration as in your bloodstream.

What’s safe:

• An occasional drink (one standard drink) is considered safe
• Wait at least 2 hours per drink before nursing
• No need to “pump and dump”—alcohol leaves breast milk as it leaves your bloodstream
• Having a drink while nursing or right after is timing-wise the safest option

Important facts:

• Alcohol peaks in breast milk 30-60 minutes after consumption (90 minutes if consumed with food)
• A 140-pound woman takes about 2-3 hours to metabolize one standard drink
• Regular or heavy drinking can affect milk supply and baby’s development
• Never bed-share or co-sleep if you’ve been drinking

Tips:

• Plan ahead if you want to have a drink at a special occasion
• Use alcohol test strips if you’re unsure whether it’s safe to nurse
• Having one glass of wine occasionally won’t harm your baby

3. Fish High in Mercury

Why it matters: Mercury accumulates in fish and can pass through breast milk, potentially affecting baby’s developing nervous system.

Avoid:

• Shark
• Swordfish
• King mackerel
• Tilefish
• Bigeye tuna

Safe options (2-3 servings per week):

• Salmon
• Shrimp
• Pollock
• Tilapia
• Catfish
• Cod
• Canned light tuna (limit albacore to 6oz per week)

Why fish is still important:

• Fish provides omega-3 fatty acids crucial for baby’s brain development
• Don’t avoid fish entirely—just choose low-mercury options
• If you don’t eat fish, consider an omega-3 supplement

4. Cow’s Milk Dairy

Why it might matter: About 2-3% of breastfed babies have a cow’s milk protein sensitivity or allergy.

Signs your baby might be sensitive:

• Excessive fussiness or crying
• Skin rashes or eczema
• Congestion or wheezing
• Blood in stool
• Severe reflux or vomiting
• Diarrhea or constipation

What to do:

• Don’t eliminate dairy unless you see clear symptoms
• If you suspect sensitivity, try eliminating all dairy for 2-3 weeks
• It takes 2 weeks for dairy proteins to clear your system
• Watch for improvement in symptoms
• Work with your pediatrician or allergist for proper diagnosis

If you eliminate dairy:

• Ensure adequate calcium intake (leafy greens, fortified foods, supplements)
• Read labels carefully—dairy hides in many processed foods
• Consider a calcium and vitamin D supplement

5. Common Gas-Causing Foods (Maybe)

The controversy: Many believe that gassy foods in mom’s diet cause gas in baby, but research doesn’t strongly support this.

Foods often blamed:

• Broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower
• Beans and legumes
• Onions and garlic
• Peppers

The truth:

• Gas from these foods doesn’t transfer through breast milk
• However, some babies might react to certain proteins or compounds in these foods
• Cultural diets vary widely, and babies around the world do fine with different cuisines

Our recommendation:

• Eat these foods normally unless you notice a specific pattern
• If baby is gassy, it’s more likely due to their developing digestive system, overfeeding, or swallowing air
• Only eliminate foods if you see a clear cause-and-effect pattern

6. Spicy Foods

The myth: Spicy foods will upset your baby’s stomach or make them fussy.

The reality: Most babies tolerate spicy foods in mom’s diet just fine. In fact, babies whose mothers eat spicy foods may be more accepting of those flavors later.

What to watch for:

• Occasional babies do seem fussier after mom eats very spicy foods
• If your baby reacts, it’s likely to specific spices or ingredients, not “spiciness” itself
• Try eliminating the specific ingredient rather than all spicy foods

Cultural perspective: Mothers in many cultures eat very spicy foods while breastfeeding without issues. Your baby is adapted to the foods you normally eat.

Foods That Require Caution

Herbs and Herbal Supplements

Some herbs can affect milk supply or pass significant compounds to baby:

May decrease milk supply:

• Peppermint (in large amounts)
• Sage
• Parsley (in large amounts)
• Oregano

Use caution with:

• Fenugreek (monitor for allergic reactions)
• Blessed thistle
• Any herbal supplement (consult healthcare provider first)

Artificial Sweeteners

• Most are considered safe in moderation (aspartame, sucralose, stevia)
• Saccharin should be avoided as it may pass into breast milk
• Excessive amounts of any artificial sweetener should be avoided

Highly Processed Foods

While not “forbidden,” be mindful:

• High in empty calories, low in nutrients
• Can affect the quality of your milk’s nutrient content
• May not support your own postpartum recovery
• Won’t harm baby directly but may not optimize nutrition

The Elimination Diet: When to Consider It

If your baby has persistent symptoms like:

• Blood or mucus in stool
• Severe eczema or skin rashes
• Chronic congestion
• Excessive fussiness or crying
• Poor weight gain
• Consistent digestive issues

Consider working with a healthcare provider on an elimination diet:

1. Start with the most common culprits: Dairy and soy (they often cross-react)
2. Eliminate completely for 2-3 weeks: No hidden sources
3. Watch for improvement: Keep a symptom diary
4. Reintroduce slowly: One food at a time
5. Monitor reactions: Wait 3-4 days between introductions

Other common allergens to consider: Eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, shellfish

Foods That Support Milk Supply

While we’re discussing foods to avoid, let’s mention some that may help:

Galactagogues (foods believed to boost supply):

• Oatmeal
• Barley
• Fennel
• Garlic
• Brewer’s yeast
• Flaxseed
• Almonds

General nutrition tips:

• Eat when hungry—breastfeeding burns 300-500 extra calories per day
• Stay well hydrated (drink to thirst)
• Include protein with every meal
• Don’t diet or restrict calories severely
• Eat plenty of fruits and vegetables

Signs to Watch in Your Baby

How do you know if a food is affecting your baby? Look for:

Immediate reactions (within hours):

• Increased fussiness
• Excessive crying
• Skin rashes or hives
• Runny nose or congestion
• Trouble sleeping

Delayed reactions (up to several days):

• Eczema
• Chronic congestion
• Persistent diaper rash
• Changes in stool (blood, mucus, diarrhea, or constipation)
• Slow weight gain

Keep a food and symptom diary to identify patterns. Sometimes what seems like a food reaction is actually:

• Normal newborn fussiness
• Developmental leaps
• Growth spurts
• Overstimulation
• Reflux unrelated to diet

Common Myths Debunked

Myth: You must avoid all dairy while breastfeeding. Truth: Only about 2-3% of babies have true cow’s milk protein sensitivity.

Myth: Chocolate will make your baby hyper. Truth: The small amount of caffeine in moderate chocolate consumption rarely affects babies.

Myth: You need a bland diet to prevent gas and fussiness. Truth: Most babies tolerate a varied, flavorful diet just fine.

Myth: You can’t eat shellfish while breastfeeding. Truth: Shellfish is safe unless you or your baby has an allergy.

Myth: Acidic foods cause diaper rash. Truth: There’s no evidence that citrus or tomatoes in your diet cause diaper rash.

Myth: You must give up coffee completely. Truth: Moderate caffeine (300mg/day) is generally safe.

Practical Guidelines

DO:

• Eat a balanced, varied diet
• Stay well-hydrated
• Listen to your body’s hunger cues
• Include plenty of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and protein
• Continue prenatal vitamins or a postnatal supplement
• Enjoy your food without excessive anxiety

DON’T:

• Restrict foods without reason
• Follow overly restrictive “breastfeeding diets” from unreliable sources
• Ignore clear patterns of food reactions in your baby
• Assume every fussy moment is food-related
• Stress excessively about your diet (stress affects milk supply more than food does!)

When to Seek Help

Contact your pediatrician or lactation consultant if:

• Your baby has blood in their stool
• Baby has severe or persistent eczema
• Your baby isn’t gaining weight properly
• You’re considering eliminating major food groups
• You’re feeling overwhelmed or restricted by dietary concerns
• Baby shows signs of allergic reaction (hives, swelling, difficulty breathing)

The Bottom Line

Unless your baby shows specific symptoms, you can and should eat a normal, varied diet while breastfeeding. The restrictions for breastfeeding mothers are far fewer than those for pregnancy. Your body is designed to make nutritious milk regardless of minor dietary variations.

Focus on eating well for your own health and recovery rather than following arbitrary restrictions. A happy, well-nourished mother is the best gift you can give your baby.

If you do notice concerning symptoms in your baby, work with healthcare professionals to identify the culprit rather than eliminating foods randomly. And remember—most babies outgrow food sensitivities within the first year.

Enjoy your food, enjoy feeding your baby, and don’t let dietary anxiety rob you of the joy of this special time.

Key Takeaways

• Most breastfeeding mothers can eat whatever they want
• Limit caffeine to 300mg/day and be cautious with alcohol
• Choose low-mercury fish and include omega-3s in your diet
• Only eliminate foods if baby shows specific symptoms
• Common “forbidden” foods (spicy food, garlic, vegetables) are usually fine
• Keep a food diary if you suspect sensitivities
• Focus on overall nutrition rather than restrictions

What has your experience been with diet and breastfeeding? Have you noticed any foods that affect your baby? Share your story in the comments!

---

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not replace professional medical advice. Always consult with your pediatrician or healthcare provider before making significant dietary changes or if you suspect your baby has a food sensitivity.